W3matchJoin

Bitcoin's Fall to $61.9k: Four Explanations, and What the Data Shows

BTC fell from above $80k to near $61.9k. We check ETF outflows, MARA's sale, MSCI and PPI against timestamps. None is proven to be the cause.

Pawnie4 min read

Four explanations circulate for bitcoin's fall: ETF outflows, a large MARA sale, MSCI dropping Strategy and Metaplanet, and a hot PPI print. Each is a real event. This article asks a narrower thing. What does each one measure, and when did it happen compared with the drop?

The move in numbers

On Coinbase BTC-USD, the daily high on 5 November was $80,843.85. The first hourly low below $69,000 was $68,442.05, in the 03:00 UTC hour on 13 November. The period low was $61,946.17, in the 01:00 UTC hour on 15 November. At 11:21 UTC on 16 November, CoinGecko's aggregate price was about $64,684.

Venues differ. The Block and CoinDesk gave slightly different lows and "lowest since" dates for 13 November, so name the source when quoting a price.

ETF outflows: the one that lines up in time

Farside's daily totals for US spot bitcoin ETFs show seven straight sessions of net outflows from 5 to 13 November. They sum to −$1,907.4m. Choosing seven sessions is our choice. From 30 October to 13 November, the 11-session total is −$2,990.2m, including a +$74.6m inflow on 4 November. These are net flows: creations minus redemptions in dollars. Farside

The outflows ran at the same time as the decline. That is a correlation. Flows can follow price as well as lead it, and the data shows nothing about investor motives. Net ETF flows are also not the same as spot BTC sold on exchanges. Farside's figures are provisional and may be revised. The Block's $1.91bn figure for the same window is not an independent check. The Block

MARA's 13,597 BTC: large, but probably earlier

MARA's 10-Q says it sold 13,597 BTC after 30 September for about $1.1bn. It used $750m to repay loans backed by bitcoin. MARA filing The shareholder letter gives an average price of about $81,039. SEC That is about 40% of the 34,012 BTC held on 30 September (our calculation).

MARA did not disclose trade dates. The average sits inside October's range of CoinGecko daily snapshots, roughly $80k to $86.5k. So "mostly before the selloff" is our inference, not a fact. The filing appeared on 9 November, after the decline had begun. This is also a different deal from MARA's March 2026 sale. Decrypt

MSCI: an equity event dated 30 November

MSCI published its November review on 11 November. Strategy is listed as a deletion from the MSCI USA Index, effective at the close on 30 November. MSCI press release MSCI USA list Metaplanet is deleted from MSCI Japan Small Cap, per The Block and Bitcoin Magazine. Bitcoin Magazine

Index funds that track these indexes sell the companies' shares, not BTC. The effective date is still ahead, so those flows have not happened. Any sentiment effect on BTC is unmeasured. Do not apply the 2025 JPMorgan estimate to this decision. It belonged to an earlier proposal.

PPI at 6.5%: the wrong print for this story

The BLS reported October PPI final demand at +6.5% over 12 months, not seasonally adjusted. The monthly figure was +0.3%, seasonally adjusted. BLS It is not CPI.

It came out at 13:30 UTC on 13 November. BTC had already traded below $69,000 about 10.5 hours earlier. In the first 10 minutes after the release, BTC rose about 1% on Coinbase, from a $69,244 candle close at 13:25 to a $70,141.87 high in the 13:35 candle.

The factor check

Factor What it measures Timing vs the drop Does it show cause?
ETF flows Net USD creations less redemptions, US spot BTC ETFs Concurrent, 5 to 13 Nov No. Correlation only; motives unknown
MARA sale 13,597 BTC sold after 30 Sep Dates undisclosed; average price points to October (our inference) No
MSCI deletion Equity index membership of two companies Announced 11 Nov; effective 30 Nov No. Share sales, not BTC
PPI 6.5% Final demand, 12-month, not seasonally adjusted Released after the $69k break; BTC rose about 1% after No

What else was cited at the time

Coverage on 13 November pointed elsewhere. CoinDesk reported liquidations above $1.3bn over 24 hours, with BTC at $677m. The Block cited $1.47bn, of which $1.31bn were longs. Both attribute the figures to CoinGlass, so the range is $1.3bn to $1.47bn. We did not access CoinGlass directly. CoinDesk

Analysts quoted named Fed hike expectations after the 10 November CPI, risk-off after Nvidia CEO turmoil, a stronger dollar and Middle East tensions. These are opinions, not proof. Neither article mentioned MARA, MSCI or PPI.

None of the four candidates is shown to be the cause, and neither is the second list. Liquidations, ETF flows and spot sales are different metrics and should not be added together.

Data snapshot: Coinbase BTC-USD candles (13 Nov 03:00 UTC hour, 15 Nov 01:00 UTC hour, 13 Nov 13:25 and 13:35 UTC candles); CoinGecko spot at 16 Nov 2026, 11:21 UTC; Farside table read 16 Nov 2026, about 11:20 UTC, with no session yet after 13 Nov. This is not investment advice and makes no price prediction.

#bitcoin#etf#markets#research

Keep reading

Back to blog